How Refreshing Your Website Can Impact Your Online Fundraising

As we mentioned in this blog post, we sent out a survey to our database at the end of last year. We compiled all of our findings and recommendations in a free guide here, but in this post, we wanted to explore one area in detail: how refreshing your website can impact your online fundraising efforts.

Of the 1,200 nonprofit professionals surveyed, an overwhelming amount said they wanted to improve the fundraising experience on their website. If you’re also looking to build or refresh your website this year, think about how you want your donors to experience your organization online. You’ll want to make sure the site offers compelling content and is easy to use. The following steps will help you do just that.

Optimize for Mobile

According to Nonprofits Source, 54% of donors worldwide “prefer to give online with a credit or debit card.” When you consider that only 11% of donors worldwide preferred direct mail, it makes sense why improving the online donor experience is crucial to an organization’s fundraising success rate.

By optimizing for mobile, you’re making it easier for your donors to pull up your website and follow the donor journeyMost website-building platforms like Squarespace and WordPress automatically optimize their templates for mobile use. If your platform isn’t optimized for mobile, figure out what you need to do—hire a developer, switch website platforms—to ensure it will be in the immediate future.

Have Clear Donate Buttons on Your Site

Once donors are on your site, you need to take the guesswork out of the process for them. Have clear calls-to-action on the website, including links to your Donate page and buttons in the menu bar and throughout your site. The donor shouldn’t have to search for where they can go to support your organization so make sure these are as visible, repetitive, and easy to understand as you can.

Provide a Recurring Monthly Gifts Option

Nonprofits Source also sheds light on how important it is to give your donors the option to become a monthly or recurring donor. According to the organization, donors who set up recurring donations “give 42% more annually, compared to one-time donations.”

Maximize Storytelling Opportunities Through Video 

In 2019, it’s not enough to have text on a webpage. Viewers are looking for images and video content as well—anything that quickly helps them understand your organization and the impact it has on the population or issue area it serves.

How are you maximizing storytelling opportunities on your current website? Are they siloed on one page or spread throughout the website where the donor is constantly reminded of the important work you’re doing? Are the stories compelling? Are the forms varied and engaging? If you haven’t already, consider how you can make the most of the testimonials, impact statements, and success stories you have on hand.

If you’re worried about cost, there are alternatives to creating expensive, highly-produced videos. Online audiences are used to engaging with videos created on an iPhone. These types of videos can also create a sense of intimacy and authenticity between you and the donor.

Examine Your Direct Mail Strategy

Finally, take a close look at how your direct mail strategy is driving traffic to your website. When you send people direct mail asks, are you only giving them the option to donate via check? If so, include an option (with easy steps laid out) for them to donate online.

If you’re not including hashtags and social media handles on those paper materials, consider doing so ASAP. This is another chance to get your donors to interact with you online and, ideally, lead them to your website.

Refresh Your Donation Landing Page

In our experience, there are three components that make up a foolproof donation landing page:

  1. OFFER – why their contribution matters

On your donation landing page, you should remind the donor why their contribution matters. Oftentimes, what you’re offering people is the opportunity to be a part of something larger than themselves.

  1. IMPACT – the specific impact their contribution has on the cause

A potential donor shouldn’t have to infer what the impact of their money will be; you need to tell them.

These impact reminders work best when tied to a compelling narrative from or proof of your work. You have to be specific on this page. This is a fundraising mistake your organization can’t afford to make.

  1. OPTIONS – the donation levels they can choose

You can create a narrative around the impact each donation tier has and give people several options for how much they want to donate.

By showing different levels of impact—tied to the dollars donated—you’re giving the donor the power to choose the specific impact they want to have. The fewer barriers in the way of clicking that Donate button, the better.

You can learn more about Kindful’s Donation Pages here.

Want to learn more? Download our free ebook to see how you can build a more robust and effective fundraising ecosystem.